Quiz: Are You Team Pumpkin Spice or Team Apple Pie?

As the leaves start to change, there’s a sense of magic in the air during the fall season. For many, fall in the U.S. means cozy sweaters, crisp evenings, and one big, seasonal question: Are you Team Pumpkin Spice or Team Apple Pie? It’s the ultimate showdown of fall flavors, each bringing with it warm, nostalgic memories and comforting traditions. Whether you’re sipping on a pumpkin spice latte or serving up a warm slice of apple pie, these flavors help define the autumn season for families across the country.

In this post, we’ll not only explore the beloved rivalry between pumpkin spice and apple pie, but we’ll also offer a fun quiz to help you discover which fall flavor represents YOU! Plus, we’ll share an exciting way to crystallize your favorite fall memories by turning photos of your family’s seasonal traditions into stunning Personalized 3D Crystals from Beyond Memories.

So, are you ready to find out which team you belong to? Let’s dive in!

Both flavors carry a world of nostalgia, but they couldn’t be more different when it comes to taste and the emotions they evoke. Pumpkin spice brings warm spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves to the forefront, while apple pie leans into the crisp, tart sweetness of baked apples wrapped in flaky, buttery goodness. Whichever flavor wins your heart, there’s no denying that both bring families together during fall festivals, gatherings, and celebrations.

Team Pumpkin Spice fans are all about the cozy feeling of spiced lattes, pumpkin bread, and even pumpkin-flavored cookies. It’s the unofficial taste of autumn, with people waiting all year for the first whiff of that cinnamon goodness.

On the other hand, Team Apple Pie holds onto the rich tradition of family recipes, apple-picking adventures, and warm pie straight out of the oven. The aroma of baked apples mixed with sugar and cinnamon wafting through the kitchen is enough to bring people together for a second (or third!) slice.

But enough talk—let’s see which flavor matches your personality. Take the quiz below to find out if you’re Team Pumpkin Spice or Team Apple Pie!

It’s a cool autumn evening. What’s your ideal way to spend it?

• A) Sipping a warm drink by the fireplace while wrapped in a cozy blanket
• B) Going for a walk to enjoy the crisp evening air and the sound of leaves crunching
• C) Baking a comforting treat and enjoying the smell wafting through the kitchen
• D) Gathering friends around a firepit for some good conversation and snacks

Which fall scent makes you feel most at home?

• A) The rich blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves—warm and inviting
• B) The earthy aroma of fallen leaves and pine trees
• C) The sweet smell of baked goods, fresh from the oven
• D) The crisp and refreshing scent of morning dew and fresh air

What’s your favorite fall tradition?

• A) Heading out to the local market for seasonal goodies and warm drinks
• B) Taking a scenic drive to enjoy the changing colors of the trees
• C) Planning a family baking day, filled with homemade treats
• D) Visiting an orchard or farm to pick seasonal produce with loved ones

When it comes to fall desserts, what are you craving?

• A) A spiced cake or warm bread with a hint of sweetness and spice
• B) A flaky pie filled with a sweet and tangy filling
• C) Soft cookies with a drizzle of glaze or frosting on top
• D) A rich tart with a buttery crust and a slightly tart center

What’s your ideal fall wardrobe?

• A) A soft scarf and sweater that scream “cozy comfort”
• B) A flannel shirt and jeans, ready for outdoor adventures
• C) A long cardigan and boots, perfect for a relaxed day inside or out
• D) A jacket and hat for bundling up during chilly morning outings

If you could plan the perfect fall weekend, what would it include?

• A) A visit to a cozy café to enjoy a warm drink while catching up with friends
• B) Hiking or walking through a forest, enjoying the crisp air and vibrant colors
• C) A laid-back day spent baking treats and enjoying them with family
• D) Spending the day at a local festival, enjoying seasonal activities and fresh produce

Mostly A’s – Team Cozy (Pumpkin): You’re all about warmth and comfort when the fall season rolls in. Whether it’s savoring a spiced drink or curling up with a blanket, your idea of fall is all about cozy moments that bring joy. You're probably into flavors that have a little spice, making you the perfect fit for Team Pumpkin!

Mostly B’s – Team Classic (Apple): You love the refreshing, crisp side of fall. Scenic walks, cool air, and traditions rooted in the outdoors bring you the most joy this season. Classic autumn vibes run through you, making you a natural fit for Team Apple!

Mostly C’s – Team Cozy (Pumpkin): For you, fall is the perfect excuse to bake and enjoy the delicious smells of the season filling your home. From baked goods to warm treats, you’re the definition of cozy, and you love celebrating the season with comforting flavors—welcome to Team Pumpkin!

Mostly D’s – Team Classic (Apple): You’re drawn to the traditional, earthy side of fall. Whether it's taking a scenic drive or spending time at an outdoor festival, you love the crisp, refreshing aspect of autumn. Your tastes are classic, making you the perfect match for Team Apple!

Whether you're loyal to Team Pumpkin Spice or devoted to Team Apple Pie, one thing is certain: fall is a season for creating moments you’ll want to remember. And now, you can capture those memories and display them in a unique and lasting way with Personalized 3D Crystals from Beyond Memories. It’s the perfect way to keep your autumn traditions close, no matter which flavor speaks to you.

So, after your next cozy gathering or family outing, don’t let those memories stay locked away in a phone or camera. Bring them to life in a stunning crystal keepsake that will preserve the magic of the season for years to come.